Jump to content

LED lighting - how is it for you?


Gary

Recommended Posts

Seem to be conflicting reports on social media about the new "white" LED lighting popping up around town

http://www.warrington-worldwide.co.uk/2015/11/06/new-white-street-lights-are-coming-on/

How are they for you?

Feel free to comment under the article as well - as the council are more likely to see you comments on the main site :wink:

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 86
  • Created
  • Last Reply

They changed all our road light a few months ago and now the whole road is much darker that it was before with just bright areas directly under the lights. 

My driveway used to be well illuminated by the old sodium lights but now it's pitch black and I even need a torch just to find the right keys and keyhole.

More importantly I live down a long cul-de-sac in what's generally regarded as a relatively crime free area but since the "Darkening" my car has been broken into twice in the space of a month and items stolen. In all my life I've never had any problems like this and yet within a couple of months of the lighting change all this happens.

Coincidence maybe but I don't for one moment think this lighting helped! (apart form making it easier for the opportunist thief!)

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

They changed all our road light a few months ago and now the whole road is much darker that it was before with just bright areas directly under the lights. 

My driveway used to be well illuminated by the old sodium lights but now it's pitch black and I even need a torch just to find the right keys and keyhole.

More importantly I live down a long cul-de-sac in what's generally regarded as a relatively crime free area but since the "Darkening" my car has been broken into twice in the space of a month and items stolen. In all my life I've never had any problems like this and yet within a couple of months of the lighting change all this happens.

Coincidence maybe but I don't for one moment think this lighting helped! (apart form making it easier for the thief!)

 

Bill :)

Coincidence or the consequences of living in a Tory Britain :wink:  Maybe you need an external light Bill, cheap and easy to fit.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I'm all in favor of anything that works well while at the same time being good for the environment It's just that these lamps don't work that well.

The light is far too concentrated into one small spot and outside of this there's virtually no illumination.

There needs to be some kind of simple plastic diffuser that could be retro fitted to spread the light out a little more evenly and that to me would improve matters greatly.

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

The old amber sodium (I presume) light we had in the close was hopeless but since they have installed the new LED (I  presume) light the dark corner of our front garden is lit up nicely, so no problem for us!.

Link to post
Share on other sites

From a light distribution point of view, compared to the traditional Amber Sodium bulbs they are rubbish spaced at the same distance. The old Amber street lights effectively  bleed illumination over a greater footprint - in Thelwall now when I walk the dogs in the dark I go from areas of pitch blackness to the isolated very bright floodlights that are the new LED street lights, which give a circle of light immediately below the pole - hence why they are taller to traditional lamp posts to try and alleviate this defect . Its obvious you need closer grouped led lights to get the same area illuminated for a worth while effect compared to the older amber Sodium  lights - was this factored into the whole life cost - I bet not as they quote like for like replacement on numbers - again someone with no technical knowledge signed up on potential cost saving that in asset efficiency terms i.e. illumination quality doesn't exist. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

They changed all our road light a few months ago and now the whole road is much darker that it was before with just bright areas directly under the lights. 

My driveway used to be well illuminated by the old sodium lights but now it's pitch black and I even need a torch just to find the right keys and keyhole.

Same for my dads road since his were done too Bill.  It's awful.   

 

Here's what I just posted under the news article before seeing this topic.

 

Ours aren’t too bad as they are at regular intervals on both sides of the road and when they were first installed I thought they were much brighter and better but they do seem to have dimmed

since they were first installed. Maybe the levels have been turned down, no idea.

 

The bottom of my dads road however is awful now the old one has been replaced. Plunged into complete darkness and you can’t see a thing. All gardens, drives and the roads turnabout are pitch black.

Certainly not very good at all for residents security or for those walking through.

 

Have to say when it was slightly foggy last week I noticed when driving in the dark that the the new lights seem to reflect on the fog and make it worse unlike the old lights that are still on other roads near here.

 

Also now the dark nights have drawn you can hardly see pedestrians walking along the pavements now especially if they are wearing darker clothing.

Surely that is dangerous and I never noticed the problem with the old lights.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My garden is darkness too now. I have always had a PIR floodlight on the corner off the house that illuminates the drive when it detects movement, but I have since put up a couple of solar PIR lights on the side of the house I bought from Lidl. Intend to replace them with dawn to dusk lights of some sort though.

 

As for pedestrians, it is hard to see them, people will need to start wearing lighter clothing or having something reflective on

Link to post
Share on other sites

Pretty much everyone I've spoken to says our road is now a whole lot darker than it was before and yet people in other areas of the town say it's much brighter and a big improvement so something isn't right. Are all the lights the same? or has Paddington been given some kind of cheap sub standard units?

Nobodies doubting their green credentials or how much better white light is compared to the orange of sodium but focussing wholly on the illumination provided, the lamps in our area are most certainly not an improvement and It seems a bit late in the day to start asking what people think.

 

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Reading Wirerob1's reply perhaps the reason that the corner of our garden is much lighter now is that the lamp post is quite close and it is just within the narrow cone of light, also now it has been pointed out that the area covered far less than the previous sodium lights. this I agree with. So all in all yet another crap job by our crap council!.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Or they could walk on the pavements

 

Or they could walk on the pavements

 

Yes, they should but they appear from behind cars wanting to cross roads, nearly knocked down a guy the other day unloading his van through the side door dressed all in dark clothing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, they should but they appear from behind cars wanting to cross roads, nearly knocked down a guy the other day unloading his van through the side door dressed all in dark clothing.

 

Yes, they should but they appear from behind cars wanting to cross roads, nearly knocked down a guy the other day unloading his van through the side door dressed all in dark clothing.

Then you were passing too closely.

Link to post
Share on other sites

While I was out and about over the weekend, I checked out some of the other roads that had LED lights.

In virtually all cases there's still a big contrast between light and dark areas despite them being higher and having some kind of diffuser on them.  

I'm sure at some point in the future the technology will get better but as it stands now the overall lighting quality has gone backwards.

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't take the bait Coffee. :mrgreen:

It does seem a bit unusual (or maybe not) that a council that claims to be so concerned about road safety should install a lighting system that could actually increase the risk of accidents.

I accept there are plus and minus points to most things in life but to my way of thinking, the economics of potential power saving seems to have been put before safety in this case.

 

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes but the problem as you know Gary is that night time photography yields some weird results unless you have a really good setup and know what your doing.

Ideally you'd need before and after shots but I've seen some of these and if we were to believe what they show then we wouldn't really have a problem. :roll:  :roll:  :roll:

 

 

Bill :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

But PJ surely people unloading in the dark and at the sides of roads should use their brains for their own safety and not wear all black/dark clothing. High viz waistcoats are only a couple of pounds or how about wearing work trousers/tops with reflective strips in.  A lot have them !

I've lost count of the number of pedestrians I've seen (well I just about seen) at night over the past week dressed in dark clothes and suddenly appearing from in between parked cars to cross roads.  Worst one was a woman all in black, pushing a black pram with a little tot walking beside also dressed in black.  You could hardly see them because the new lights weren't lighting up the area they were crossing at.  Silly people !!

And don't get me started on some cyclists.... they clearly have a death wish !!! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

If everyone goes out tonight and takes a picture of their street scene under the new lights I will forward them to the council and seek clarification.

 

 

Yes but the problem as you know Gary is that night time photography yields some weird results unless you have a really good setup and know what your doing.

Ideally you'd need before and after shots but I've seen some of these and if we were to believe what they show then we wouldn't really have a problem. :roll:  :roll:  :roll:

 

 

Bill :)

Bill is correct as I've already tried to take photos of ones round here and also my dads road with both my cameras and also my mobile phone. 

None gave a true representation of the actual light regardless of the settings I used.  

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...